Is anyone else conflicted about acquiring D&D 2024 books?
Let me explain my reservations.
I'm quite happy with fifth edition D&D. I'm open to learning other systems but not necessarily a new edition. 5e by no means is the perfect system, but it does everything I absolutely need it to. It engages without overwhelming the player. It's rules-medium (neither heavy nor lite). And yes, the crafting is useless and the CR-rating is laughably broken, but those are things I can overlook for the most part.
With that said, I had always thought that I would acquire the "new edition" of D&D's Dungeon Master's Guide. This deliberation came to mind when they initially talked about the next iteration - before the debate of 6e, 5.5e, One D&D, etc. It was just a thought of "Oh, it would be nice to get more help on the DM-ing side".
And then we had the OGL fiasco last year January and I found myself reconsidering.
I've not moved away from 5e, but I have found myself moving away from WotC in that I don't want to give them any more money than I already have. I've always looked for my homebrew for third-party content as well as the actual core stuff, because my players know their monsters too well and bringing diversity to a 10-year-old edition is always welcome. I welcome the introduction of Tales of the Valiant from Kobold press that promises compatibility to 5e while being its own game. I've already pre-ordered their GM Guide that's to come out in November-ish(?) and I'm incorporating a number of their monsters into my game.
Okay, that was a bit of a tangent.
Basically I don't feel like I should encourage WotC/Hasbro's shenanigans with my money. The prices for hard-cover books have almost doubled and the content has not made up for the price. I'm not happy with the idea of AI DMs, AI Art, AI story creation. (The topic of artificial intelligence is a vast one and I'm not going to get into it besides saying that if it hits on story-telling, art, writing, and music - things that we incorporate into our culture - I'm very iffy about it. That cuts the livelihoods of creatives and doesn't give us anything other than recycled plagiarism to some extent.) WotC has had more than one AI whoopsie that was noticed by their customers.
Okay, that turned into another tangent.
Maybe all the tangents are the whole point and problem in supporting them by hauling out (a lot of) money for the new DMG. Every time I think about how nice it would be and how pretty the new books look, I wonder how they're attempting to screw us over next. And that's not the kind of thinking that inspires me to take the plunge.
